When Coun. Mike Del Grande
poured over the city's 2006 annual financial report last week, he discovered to
his surprise that
Toronto
's population has increased a mere 0.4% since 2002.
Notwithstanding that, the
report and its five-year fiscal review showed the
Scarborough
chartered accountant just how much city spending and its debt has jumped during
the same period.
According to the report, the
city's total wage bill increased 24% from $3.1 billion to $3.8 billion last
year.
The city is paying 82% more
interest on long-term debt (raised for capital projects) -- $202 million vs.
$110 million in 2002. The interest payments come out of the operating budget,
despite Mayor David Miller's nonsensical contentions that cancelling capital
projects will have no impact on the city's deficit woes. The report says debt
charges are now the second largest component of the city's property tax bill.
It's enough to make one see
red, especially given the repeated assertions by Miller, his cabal of
like-minded seals and their left-wing media mouthpieces that the city is not fat
and there is no other option but to approve two controversial City of Toronto
Act taxes at next week's council meeting.
I'd had enough of the spin. So last week Del Grande and I spent two days looking
for savings and our own revenue tools to replace the $356 million anticipated
from the new land transfer and vehicle ownership taxes.
We found some $440.9 million
-- $419.4 million from what I've called the Big Ticket Items like wages and
benefits. There was another $21.5 million from what the socialists like to call
"chicken feed" -- the small yet symbolic cuts to councillor office
budgets, their wage hikes and free food, the city's grants, special events,
cultural and plant watering budgets that Coun. Rob Ford raises year after year.
I believe we barely
scratched the surface. We deliberately avoided the city's generous union
contracts, which come up for renewal next April. The mayor should be talking
concessions but won't given his close ties to CUPE.
Nevertheless, here's how we
arrived at the $419 million:
4 NOT-SO-FAIR WAGES: The
fair wage policy -- which demands all companies wanting to do business with the
city pay close to union wages -- is one of the biggest areas to crack. The
city's own reports show that at $42.58/hr.,
Toronto
's average "fair" wage is $15 above the provincial average and $8
above
Oshawa
's. Based on a figure of $1 billion for city contracts requiring the fair wage,
we lowered the average rate by a conservative $5 for savings of $123 million.
4 NOTE THIS: Eagle-eyed Del
Grande discovered a note in the report that Toronto Hydro will repay its
$980-million loan from the city starting with $245 million on Dec. 31. CFO Joe
Pennachetti told me the money will be put in a Strategic Infrastructure Fund to
pay for the waterfront, the Spadina subway and environmental projects. It seems
about $90 million of that will be used to fund the mayor's pet Climate Change
Initiatives, like a $42-million energy conservation fund and a $20-million Green
Energy fund -- shameless, given that he opted to delay opening hockey rinks
until January and to close community centres on Mondays. I took the $90 million
to help plug the deficit hole. True, it's a one-time fix, but Miller already set
that precedent by selling off $60 million in hydro poles in 2005 to balance the
books.
4 WAGES? TAKE A HIKE: It was
generous enough that the city handed its 47,000 unionized employees a 3.25% wage
hike last year. But according to the report, the wage bill increased 5.5% to
account for merit pay and overtime. We knocked off that extra 2.25% for a
savings of $86 million. Using the same figures, we also implemented a wage
freeze for all of the city's non-unionized employees (about 20% of the
workforce) for a savings of $18.9 million and cut their generous benefits (about
25% of the wage bill) by 4% for another $7.8 million in savings.
4 TAXES? A NECESSARY TOOL:
We figure Premier
Dalton
McGuinty will make good on his promise to upload $38 million in social service
costs next year. We opted to share the pain and raise property taxes by 6% for
an extra $33 million. We also assumed there'd be $20 million in assessment
growth from the rash of new condo developments across the city.
4 DEBT WASTE: Council's
recent decision to purchase $54 million in new recycling and residual waste
carts next year makes Waste Diversion Toronto's Rod Muir bristle. He thinks it's
evidence of "Miller in Microcosm ... spending on stuff that seems to
benefit city workers more than anything." We axed the $54-million proposal,
which will be debt financed at around 5%, for a savings of $2.7 million in
interest costs and went with Muir's suggestion to use bag tags (at 15 cents
each) instead.
Del Grande challenges Miller
& Co. to take a look at these cuts before he goes to taxpayers for more tax
money -- that this proves the city is not as efficient as the mayor and his
media mouthpieces constantly maintain.
"It's like an onion ...
you have to continually peel," he said. "You have to look under the
numbers and question the numbers."
---
PLUGGING THE CITY'S DEFICIT
HOLE
BIG TICKET ITEMS
1. Reduce city's average
fair wage rate of $42.50/hr. on $1 billion of contracted-out services by $5 to
bring it more in line with province and other GTA cities.
SAVINGS: $123 million
2. Use $90 million of
$245-million Toronto Hydro note, which comes due Dec. 31 and will be allocated
to mayor's Climate Change Initiatives.
REVENUE FIX: $90 million
3. Eliminate 2% wage hikes
for merit and OT over and above the 3.25% negotiated (2006) increase contained
in the $3.8-billion wage budget for last year.
SAVINGS: $86 million
4. Implement a wage freeze
for city's non-unionized staff (about 20% of the total head count).
SAVINGS: $18.9 million
5. Cut non-unionized
benefits by 4% (from 25%).
SAVINGS: $7.8 million
6. Provincial upload
committed by Premier in election.
REVENUE FIX: $38 million
7. Raise property taxes 6%
to spread the pain (3% more than expected).
REVENUE FIX: $33 million
8. New assessment on 10,000
condo units coming on stream in 2008.
REVENUE FIX: $20 million
9. Cancel $54-million
capital purchase of garbage carts and bins and use bag tags (at 15 cents each)
instead. Savings would be on debt financed at 5%.
SAVINGS: $2.7 million
TOTAL BIG-TICKET ITEMS:
$419.4 million
THE CHICKEN FEED CATEGORY
1. Reduce councillor office
budgets by $23,100 to $30,000.
SAVINGS: $1 million
2. Roll back wage hikes
given to councillors and the mayor in 2007 (over standard 1.9% COLA increase).
SAVINGS: $284,740
3. Cut council's free food
and coffee.
SAVINGS: $80,000
4. Cut council conference
and travel budget.
SAVINGS: $50,000
5. Cut council grants budget
by 10%.
SAVINGS: $4.1 million
6. Cut Tenant Defence fund
grants by 10%.
SAVINGS: $6,700
7. Cut culture and special
events budgets by 10%.
SAVINGS: $2.1 million
8. Cut plant watering
service in city buildings.
SAVINGS: $77,000
9. Eliminate
Toronto
Water radio ad campaign Re: Summer lawn watering.
SAVINGS: $210,000
10. Eliminate door-to-door
waste and water newsletters.
SAVINGS: $665,000
11. Cancel lobbyist
registry.
SAVINGS: $400,000
12. Cut Clean and
Beautiful
City
program (including secretariat).
SAVINGS: $1.6 million
13. Recoup half the cost
($54.50) of the 18,860 free monthly Metropasses given to TTC employees,
retirees, councillors and assorted others.
REVENUE FIX: $11 million
TOTAL CHICKEN FEED: $21.5
million
GRAND TOTAL: (Ka-ching, ka-ching)
$440.9 million